Celtel
Are ICTs an Effective Alternative to Aid?
With Dambisa Moyo sounding off in Wired magazine that we should Cut Off Aid to Africa, that is favor investment over grants to government, its time we ask ourselves if information and communication technologies are a help or hindrance to development.
In our search for answers, or at least a in-depth discussion of ICT's impact on Africa, may I suggest that we start with this great Vox Africa interview with Tunde Adebayo, Ken Banks, Tim Unwin, and Samuel Burke:
In this video, Ken Banks has a provocative statement when he says:
I think we can argue that if mobile phones were a World bank or international aid project, we would be no where near where we are now
I wonder if he remembers that the IFC, the financing arm of the World Bank, helped found Celtel, one of Africa's largest mobile phone companies before it was bought by MTC? But he does have a point in the rapid spread of mobile phone being mainly free of international development influences.
Yet the bigger question around a second act. Are mobile phones a fluke, or can there be other private industry driven ICT's that have just as great, or even greater impact of the long-term development of Africa?
Like what you read? Then subscribe to ICTworks updates via RSS, Email, or Twitter
.
Wayan Vota
InveneoWayan Vota is a technology expert focused on appropriate information and communication technologies (ICT) for rural and underserved areas of the developing world. He is a Senior Director at Inveneo and is the editor of ICTworks

In Uganda, Teacher training institutions do not take computer training as a serious ingredient to teacher education, when teachers are...
Konza City is a great idea. All big achievements are started by brave men and women who have dared to think and act out of the ordinary...
Bravo Lindsay, great post! I came across a similar problem 10 years ago working on a project in Guatemala. The objective of the project...
I very much enjoyed reading the guide full of sensible information and lots of great tips. Thanks to Inveneo for making it and thanks...
Lindsay,here in cameroun all is politisee;a taecher 's salaries can not allow him to buy laptop and survive,we waiting all for...